Are the Utes the best?

Rice-Eccles Stadium, home of the Runnin' Utes
The Utah Utes just finished a 13-0 season and ended up #2 in the AP Poll and #4 in the USA Today Coaches’ Poll. Should they be #1?
Before I begin, you should know I’m not a Utah fan, I’m a BYU fan; however, I do route for the Utes and other Mountain West teams when they aren’t playing BYU. As my co-worker says, if I route for BYU and Utah I can’t lose; either my tithing wins or my taxes.
Utah beat perennial powerhouse Alabama in the Sugar Bowl 31-17. In the BCS Championship game, Florida (13-1) beat Oklahoma (12-2). Did Utah deserve a chance to play in the championship game? No. Do they deserve to be #1 after beating Alabama? Probably not. Here’s why:
Many people argue that Utah’s perfect record should have automatically qualified them for the championship game and the #1 spot. I disagree. Schedule strength is important, but more importantly, the national champion, just as in any sport with a tournament, is the best team at the end of the season. Florida lost to Mississippi by 1 point in September. Does that make them worse than Utah in January? Not necessarily.
After their loss and up until the bowl season, Florida beat three teams currently ranked in the top 25, including one top 10 team (Alabama). Utah also beat three teams currently in the top 25, including one top 10 team (TCU). But Florida’s only close win was against Alabama (31-20). Utah barely squeaked by five teams (three unranked and two games at home). I think Florida’s resume outshines Utah’s by far.
Oklahoma beat four teams currently in the top 25, including one top 10 team (TCU). Their only loss was to #4 Texas in October. In their last five games of the regular season, Oklahoma scored 60+ points with an average point margin of 35 points, and against three top 25 teams. Oklahoma definitely deserved to be in the championship game.
Utah’s misfortune is that they hadn’t beaten an Alabama during the regular season. The voters had no reason whatsoever to believe Utah was the best team in the nation. Considering their convincing bowl victory over Alabama, Utah very well could have beaten Florida or Oklahoma. But maybe Texas, USC, or even TCU could have too.
Given the current system, I don’t think Utah should have been in the championship game, and I think the voters did right to crown Florida the champions. They seem to be the best team. But I do think Utah, and the other teams mentioned, deserved a chance to play for the championship. The only way to do that is with a playoff. Hope springs eternal.
I know this is long, but one final thought: who really cares? Why are Americans obsessed with knowing who’s the best? Why do we need a ranking or a trophy to validate our performance or self-worth? Why can’t we just play or watch sports and enjoy the atmosphere and competition?
Football is a lot of fun, but it’s just a game. Time to move on.
What do you think?

